Adsense Rectangle Sidebar

October 11, 2014

Julep Trick & Treat Mystery Box Spoilers

Updated 10/18: Now with 3 different versions of the mystery box, mystery polish, and large add on.

The Julep Trick & Treat Mystery Box spoilers are here! I will update this post with the mystery add on spoilers, and any other versions that appear, so check back! This box is still available.

Trick & Treat Mystery Box version 1- ($24.99/$100+ value)

Elixir Organic Moroccan Argan Oil - ($24/$12.50 Maven Sale)

Mighty Nail & Cuticle Serum - ($28/$10 Maven Sale)

Mask Noir - ($32/$25.60 Maven)

Estelle - ($14/$11.20 Maven)

Lola - ($14/$11.20 Maven)

Tatiana - ($14/$11.20 Maven)

Kendra - ($14/$11.20 Maven)

2 Twistbands - ($4) *Not sold separately*

Total Value:
$144/$96.90 Maven

Trick & Treat Mystery Box version 2- ($24.99/$100+ value)

Brilliance Glycolic Scrub - ($23/$18.40 Maven)

Luxe Care Hand Cream - ($20/$16 Maven)

Blank Canvas Mattifying Eye Primer - ($22/$10 Maven Sale)

1 Nail Mask - ($6/$2 Maven Sale)

Beatrix - ($14/$11.20 Maven)

Josephine - ($14/$11.20 Maven)

Faye - ($14/$11.20 Maven)

Valerie - ($14/$11.20 Maven)

Total Value:
$127/$91.20 Maven

Trick & Treat Mystery Box version 3- ($24.99/$100+ value)

Sweep Eyeshadow Palette Neutrals - ($24/$19.20 Maven)

Eyeshadow Brush - ($18/$14.40 Maven)

Blank Canvas Mattifying Eye Primer - ($22/$17.60 Maven Sale)

Doublestep Foot Treatment and Friction Stick - ($22/$17.60 Maven)

Estelle - ($14/$11.20 Maven)

Jodie($14/$11.20 Maven)

Catrina - ($14/$11.20 Maven)

Total Value:
$128/$102.40 Maven

icon icon 
Mystery Polish - ($4.99/$14 value)

Leah - ($14/$11.20 Maven)

Total Value:
$14/$11.20 Maven

Mystery Add-On - ($9.99/$42 value)

Major Mystery Add-On - ($14.99/$52 value)

Clean Slate Polish Remover Single Use Pad Kit - ($10/$8 Maven)

Layne($14/$11.20 Maven)

Nic($14/$11.20 Maven)

Jet($14/$11.20 Maven)

Total Value:
$52/$41.60 Maven

What do you think of the Trick & Treat Mystery Box spoilers so far? Let me know in the comments!

Julep Mavens can customize their box as much (or as little) as they like. Sign up for 1 month and pay $24.99/month, or sign up for 3 months and pay only $19.99/month! Take the style quiz and enter FREEBOX at checkout to get your first box free, just pay $2.99 for shipping!

For all other Julep Maven reviews click here.

Julep Beauty Inc.

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links!


  1. Thanks for posting. I'm for sure passing now. They told the truth about the fall colors, but I already have Estelle and I'm not interested in the products. I don't usually go for mystery boxes anyway, but thought after all the complaints about the last couple that Julep might pull out all the stops with this box. Guess not.

    1. Nope, I had the feeling it might be more on trend for the season and holiday, but most of it I already have. Incidentally from mystery boxes from the beginning of the year.

  2. They must have a huge backstock of Tatiana because this is like the 4th box I've seen it in.

    Also the mask noir was in this month's Maven box. Why put it in the mystery box too?

    1. The Mask Noir has been a product for over a year, this month's mask is a different one.

  3. I kind of want it for the products and Estelle but i don't know if it's worth 25 dollars for me...I already have tatiana and kendo and am not so interested in lola.

    1. Looks like once again there are different versions, so you could get something different if you decide to get a box!

  4. After all that reassurance that Julep had listened and we'd be getting "exactly what you'd expect in a Halloween themed box," it seems nobody was actually listening at all. Woohoo, one polish in each box is black. I guess that makes it Halloween themed? The themed boxes they did for Maven with the decals were spot on. Why couldn't they do something similar for this?

    And seriously, how difficult is it to keep track of which polishes have been in a recent mystery box or add-on and put a moratorium on them for, say, 6 mos or so so we don't all have 4 bottles of the same colour. Mix it up, make some new colours, do something other than just unload stale stock. :(

    1. Until people stop buying them, they will continue to use mystery boxes as a way to unload overstock product. Unfortunately, I don't think it will change, which is why I stopped buying them :(

  5. Thanks for the spoilers! You saved me once again. Going to pass on this one. :)

  6. I received my box today and it's completely different from what's listed above, and I didn't receive my mystery add on! Very disappointed! :(

    1. They have been known to do different mystery box versions, it sounds like you received a new version not seen yet! Would you be willing to share what you got so I can update this post? Also, email or call about the missing add on, they will take care of it for you :)

  7. Ok I will do that, thank you! This is my first time purchasing a mystery box and didn't know they had such bad reviews until I had already purchased mine and THEN did a little digging. Bad choice on my part. But in my box I received the eye shadow brush, the neutrals eye shadow palette, the blank canvas eye primer, the double step foot treatment , and three nail polishes in the colors Estelle, Jodie, and Catrina.

  8. I'm dying to know what the add ons are!

  9. Would the major mystery add on be 3 polishes and a product? That seems right for the pricing. If so, I believe that that add on is Layne, Nic, Jet, and Clean Slate Polish Remover Pads. And the single polish add on is Leah.

    (Per this post:

  10. My box was neither of these. o.O

  11. I'm extremely disappointed. I got the mystery box (value $100+) and the major add-on (value $52). The total of what I got was $138. Plus I seem to get the same stuff every mystery box. As a result I have 5 doublesteps, 5 hand & cuticle sticks, and 4 Estelles. I think I'm dumping my subscription.

  12. ^ Anon is correct. I bought that one. Add-on number 2 ($9.99) is 3 polishes. Roc Solid, Payton and Millie.

    1. Thanks for the confirmation, I'll add it as soon as I can.

  13. Thanks, I'll add it as soon as I get a chance.

  14. Just got my box: Mint Condition Pedi Creme, Mighty nail and cuticle serum, Vanish drops, Lacey, Veronica, Beatrix, Chloe, bag of candy corn. I guess the candy corn and Beatrix make it Halloween? A sparkly purple or sparkly bright green would have been fun/more on theme instead of Veronica or Lacey I think. ::shrug:: I'm just happy I didn't get stuck with the eyeshadow palette set box again.


Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.